In early 2007, I was working for Carphone Warehouse (CPW) in the PR team, when the CEO and founder, Charles Dunstone, walked into the Press Office area with his mobile phone in hand.
He had a journalist from The Times on hold, asking for a comment in relation to offensive remarks made during Channel 4’s ‘Celebrity Big Brother’ TV programme. The industry regulator, Ofcom, had received two hundred complaints that day.
CPW was the sponsor of ‘Big Brother’ and its CBB spin-off at the time, which is why the journalist was pressing Charles for a comment.
“What’s going on?” Charles asked.
I hadn’t watched the programme but it didn’t surprise me that someone had said or done something offensive. After all, ‘Big Brother’ was designed to create conflict between its contestants.
On this occasion however, the conflict in the house had gone too far and what quickly followed was a full-blown international PR crisis for both Channel 4 and CPW.
Allegations of racism and bullying had begun to emerge from the house. Britain's original reality TV personality Jade Goody, and others, had made ugly remarks about the Bollywood star, Shilpa Shetty. The remarks and the bullying got worse as further episodes were broadcast.
The resulting public, media and regulatory scrutiny was intense! Over the next couple of days, Ofcom was inundated with tens of thousands of complaints and the story was headline news across the UK media landscape. CPW’s phone lines were jammed with furious customers threatening to boycott the brand unless it cancelled its sponsorship.
The row then became an international issue. The Prime Minister at the time, Tony Blair, faced questions in Parliament. Gordon Brown, the UK Chancellor, happened to be visiting India hoping to improve economic ties. Instead, he found himself answering awkward questions about what Shilpa Shetty’s treatment said about Britain as a country.
In short, the situation became so toxic so quickly that CPW withdrew its sponsorship of the programme. The announcement was widely welcomed by the public and the brand actually received some plaudits in the media.
The same cannot be said for Channel 4 or Jade Goody. Channel 4 was later found to have breached the broadcasting code by Ofcom. And Jade Goody's reputation was torn down by the same media titles that had built her up in the first place.
At the time of the crisis, I was responding to journalists and media outlets from around the world who called CPW’s Press Office. To be honest, I found the whole experience thrilling and exhilarating! To be close to the centre of a major news story is very exciting, providing you personally aren’t the story of course! But it was only much later that I fully appreciated the fact that the row was actually a landmark, not only for British culture, but also for crisis communications.
In January 2007, a relatively new and emerging channel was just beginning to be used as a powerful platform to voice outrage, shape opinions, and to demand the cancellation of a corporate sponsorship. Social media.
The fallout and public backlash from CBB provided a glimpse of the new world that professional communicators would have to contend with. Cancel culture, the role social media can play in damaging the reputation of a brand, and the incredible speed at which an incident or remark can snowball and be amplified around the world via the internet.
For modern communications professionals, the CBB racism row provided valuable lessons in modern crisis management.
Tell your story and tell it first
The first rule of crisis comms is that you must be on the front foot. You must shape the narrative and the story, because if you don’t, plenty of others will do it for you. The media, your customers and commentators will be quick to share their views online. The CBB row demonstrated how imperative it is for brands to tell their stories first in a modern connected world.
Live and breathe your mission statement and company values
Channel 4’s initial reaction was to downplay the crisis and CPW initially pointed to legal restrictions, which meant that a corporate sponsor was not allowed to influence the content of a programme. Neither approach washed with the public, and only served to increase outrage. The public then, and even more so now, expect brands to take a stand and to act with integrity and transparency.
Many brands talk about putting customers at the centre of their business, doing the right thing, valuing diversity etc, in their mission statements and company values. During a crisis, brands should lean into these commitments and walk the talk. Live and breathe your brand’s mission and values, otherwise they will be thrown back in your face.
Reverse engineer your response
You need to find and agree on an exit strategy fast! What does a successful outcome look like and how do we get there quickly?
As professional communicators, our job is to protect our brand’s reputation. Be aware however, that others in your business may have other priorities, commercial priorities for example. But what price can you place on your brand’s reputation?
Is it too late now to say sorry?
CBB took place a few months before the launch of the first iPhone, before smartphones were in every pocket, and just as social media was beginning to establish itself as a powerful platform.
But even in today’s connected world, people still crave human emotions. It’s OK to say sorry, we messed up and we’re going to do better - although run the wording by your legal team first!
Above all, demonstrate empathy, honesty, and humility. The public won’t necessarily judge you for having a crisis but they will absolutely judge the way you respond to the crisis.
Call in the A-Team
The best comms teams already have crisis comms responders in place, which include representatives from across their organisations, who can be alerted and summoned to join a crisis call in minutes. This will include IT professionals, engineers, legal, IR and comms members of course.
Each department will have nominated primary and secondary team members to deputise in case of absences. And time zones will have been factored in to ensure a seamless crisis response across all comms channels at all times.
Sing from the same song sheet
Your crisis comms must be consistent. By this I mean consistent messaging and tone across all channels. Your reactive statement, company spokespeople, social media channels, customer emails and contact centre IVR must all sing from the same song sheet, and be updated regularly as the crisis evolves.
Don’t forget your internal audience
There might be a temptation for comms professionals to focus on their external stakeholders during a crisis, the media and customers etc, but this is a big mistake.
Your internal stakeholders matter just as much as your external ones. They are your brand ambassadors, they have access to social media, and you should expect that journalists will be in contact with them. Don’t forget your internal audience!
Keep calm and carry on
There can be a lot of pressure on a comms team during a PR crisis. Both the external and internal spotlight are on you. Personally, I always enjoy the scrutiny, but set aside any feelings you may have, stay focused, keep calm and carry on.
Check in regularly with your crisis response team and agree actions, carry on scanning all channels to see what your internal and external stakeholders are saying and reporting. Carry on being consistent and ensuring everyone is singing from the same song sheet. Carry on demonstrating empathy. And get to your exit point quickly.